Well, I’d all but killed this particular site, but in the end decided to leave it open just so I’d have a space to go off-topic. I host images on this domain anyway, no harm in having a blog attached for the occasional spouting off. So tonight I made my way through my Google Reader and came upon a new post from the eBay Collectors blog which found me composing such a lengthy note to Share that I decided it’d just be better as a post. And so here we are.
I want to like the eBay Collectors blog. Shoot, I want to love it. I came upon it about a month ago when Richard Brewer-Hay of eBay Ink tweeted about it and am sad to say I had immediate misgivings. My problems then are the same I’ll expand upon in a moment. But first, why do I want to love this blog?
As a vintage collectibles dealer who makes much of their living through eBay I love anything that potentially breathes life into the Collectibles categories. These spaces are still the best game in town for the vintage collectibles dealer to connect with the largest base of potential buyers but those of us who sell there often tremble with each new eBay Announcement fearing that we’ll be further marginalized at the sake of more commodity items all the while being commoditized ourselves. So in my mind the eBay Collectors blog was a major step and I commend eBay and it’s author, Ivanka, for putting it together.
Now don’t get me wrong, there are some good posts over there, though those aren’t the ones that set me off–seemingly common sense to us eBay vets, recent posts like “Save My Search” and “How to Find Events in Your Area” are valuable, especially coming from a collectors slant (Ivanka even links out to CollectorsWeekly.com in the latter! Oh wait, that link goes to a 404 page. Here’s some CollectorsWeekly link-love to make up for eBay Collectors lost link.).
Ivanka’s latest post is Marilyn Monroe’s $57k Dress and Other Top Sold Items – June 2010. Okay, never mind that we’re now in August, here’s my gripe: I’ve been doing this my whole life and I ain’t never laying out $57k for anything. You have a spare $57k? If you do, great, but I’m betting you’re in the minority. Am I saying eBay shouldn’t report on the sale of Marilyn’s $57k dress or the other Top Sellers from June (including items such as a rare Beatles EP at $99k all the way down to a 52 Topps Mantle at a paltry $15,500). No, there’s a place for that, it is newsworthy, but that place, I believe, is as a smaller part of an overall more populated blog.
Here’s what I was going to share on Google before I pulled back to create this post:
I don’t like the way this eBay Collectors blog is going. Most eBayer’s can’t afford the type of stuff being covered and the ones who can are much better informed than this space can attempt to do. The high dollar items chosen for coverage also perpetuate the get-rich quick mindset of casual, or shall I say, non, collectors, ie: those looking for an attic score. Bring it down some, cover the $100 to $2,000 items and the site would be a hit, assuming that is that the coverage comes with some knowledge backing it. This doesn’t contribute anything, it’s more “blow our own horn” PR type stuff about eBay being the venue which sold these treasures.
…And I was going to keep going. My point is that this type of post on the eBay Collectors blog is not for collectors, it’s for eBay. Share the most expensive and record-breaking type deals consummated on the site for collectibles, yes, but limiting the focus to them alone just makes this another eBay PR station with no true value for the collector.
Since it’s April launch the post count on the eBay Collectors blog has been 3 (April), 2 (May and June), and 5 (July). Good to see it on the rise and I’m really not one to talk since I haven’t posted to this vagabond space since May (and yeah, that was just an import from another site I’ve since killed), but what I’d like to propose is to grow the eBay Collectors blog with meaningful posts about collectibles that are affordable to the larger mass of collectors bidding and buying on the site. Go through some of the excellent guides contributed to the site by other dealers and collectors, point to them. Check out some of the items capturing the most bids which aren’t necessarily the items selling for the most dollars.
Note: This early post, given an URL with the word “test” in it was a step in the right direction I believe – eBay’s Comic Book Superhero Themed Auction. More of that please.
Just please don’t make it a freak show. And that’s what these items are, freaks, or better put, winning lottery tickets among the 99.99% of other vintage collectible and antique items that actually support the site. As I mentioned in the cribbed section above, people who have the bank account to support these purchases have much better information pointing them towards the sale. Once more, I don’t resent these type posts so much because they’re there, but because of their prominence owing to the lack of the other type of posts.
Here’s another idea–I honestly don’t know how much experience Ivanka has in the collectibles arena, and I don’t mean to be insulting when I say this, but why not put out a call for guest posts from experienced collectors/dealers? You provide the space, they provide the content and in return you give your customers a boost with a link out to their eBay Store/ID/Sales Page. Shoot, give me a link to my eBay Store and I’ll submit the first article!
In summary, love the idea, not a fan of the execution. Love still being on eBay’s map, hate not being able to relate to the posts. Want more, but want better. Vintage fans, collectors, dealers, what do you think of the eBay Collectors blog (be nice!).









